puddle and ocean

How to Avoid a Major Hiring Mistake

With baby boomers retiring in droves, organizations are rebuilding. As they do, hiring managers and strategic managers must choose their teams wisely to successfully weather the workforce transition.

When making hiring decisions, managers need to pay careful attention to the two types of candidates they’ll encounter: those with the character depth of an ocean and those with the character depth of a puddle.

In my experience, I’ve seen there are a lot of serious folks who aren’t looking to move around. They want to find something that is important to them and work where they’re appreciated and can build loyalty. I call these people “Oceans.” Sounds ideal, right? Except that, if a hiring manager has been told to focus on innovation and change, they may very well overlook the Oceans in favor of the charming up-and-comer who claims they’ve got some must-have innovation that the company needs. Of these candidates, I say “beware.” Their glitzy display may be cover for the fact that they’re as shallow as a puddle and will ultimately do no good for your organization.

How to Spot a Puddle

I bet you can think of at least one Puddle you’ve had the misfortune to step in during your career. Here are their typical traits:

Puddles are chameleons: Puddles are highly intelligent, exceptionally charming, and can turn their traits on a dime to please whoever they feel will benefit them the most. If they come across as the next leader in your organization, it’s because that’s exactly the persona that they’re carefully cultivating.

Puddles are driven by extreme ambition: They have goals in mind and do not care what they have to do to reach them. Once the newness of a job wears off, Puddles are looking for the next advancement. They tend to be job-jumpers or to create power struggles within the workplace—with the idea that the power struggle is to their advantage.

Puddles lie, a lot: Without depth of character, there’s nothing to prevent Puddles from lying to get what they want.

Puddles have no loyalty: They will turn on those who are closest to them in a heartbeat if they feel it will benefit them. They’ll express deep but insincere remorse afterward.

Puddles rely on appearances to get by: Puddles can appear to be good workers. Often, their goal is to please the person above them, all the while planning on how to get rid of that person. They’re nice to the people below them only when their behavior is visible. Otherwise they’re rude, dismissive, or discard the “underling” all together.

How to Get to the Ocean

Oceans are your great employees and serious leaders. When Oceans are in leadership positions, they bring excellence to an organization. Hopefully, you’ll recognize some of these traits in the people around you:

Oceans are not always so charming at first: An Ocean can seem boring or even misanthropic at first. It takes time to get to know them because, if they do allow you in their lives, it’s usually for a lifetime. They want to build a relationship, not have a superficial foundation.

Oceans are truthful and reliable: You can always count on the ocean, time after time, to be reliable and truthful, even if it’s difficult. They say what they mean and they mean what they say. You can truly trust them with your confidences and the assignments you give them.

Oceans are ambitious, too—but not destructively so: Oceans are capable of having great innovative ideas, but they come as the result of a deep, all-encompassing thought process, which takes time. They think through all of the issues in order to arrive at meaningful answers. The Ocean can also be ambitious, but not at the cost of others. They are the ones who lift up those around them as they’re on their way to the top.

Oceans are highly loyal: They are highly loyal, but they may appear a little stand offish at first because the ocean depth of loyalty that they give does not come easily. Once they feel they can trust you, there is no limit to that bond.

Oceans are amazing employees and leaders: These are the team members you want to build your company on. They will go out of their way for your company and your customers every time.

Oceans are deep: One last trait of the Ocean is the depth of their spiritual wisdom and insight. They make great mentors, and one of their joys in life is to share guidance and wisdom with others.

To Avoid Stepping in a Puddle, Do a Depth Sounding

Puddles get hired because they’re expert at creating the perception of being innovative. They’re flashy up-and-comers, but they may not care about the consequences and the human cost of their ill-conceived ideas. Oceans, on the other hand, are innovative, but their priorities are long-term thinking and team-building. As companies rebuild their workforces, they’ll undoubtedly find their Oceans are still producing long after their Puddles have dried up.

So, the next time you’ve got a flashy candidate in the interview process, do a depth sounding. By which I mean, test that person’s character and take careful note of their behavior and history. Ask them questions and see if their responses are “we”-focused or “me”-focused. Can you count on this person for their honesty? Do others feel they can be comfortable with them? In what ways have they proven themselves loyal? How do they behave under pressure and stress? Apply some heat to them and see what happens–a puddle boils much more quickly than an ocean.

Depth sounding isn’t difficult, but it must be done. And if you find you a Puddle in front of you, step around it.